Last Friday evening, a passenger van carrying a high school basketball team collided with a transport truck, killing 7 students, a teacher, and injuring 4 others on board. Today, the town of Bathurst, located in northeastern New Brunswick, will hold funerals for the students who lost their lives. A separate funeral will be held tomorrow for the teacher.
Our hearts and our condolences go out to those affected by this tragedy.
In writing this commentary, I want to make it clear that fault for this collision should not be placed on either of the drivers involved, because it should not. It is almost beyond comprehension the devastation caused by this event and the effect that it will have on those who were in control of the vehicles. The driver of the van was a member of the small community and the team’s coach. He lost his wife and 7 members of his team on that day. The driver of the transport was not physically injured in the crash but the emotional scars of this collision will remain with both drivers for the rest of their lives.
Recent news stories are focusing on the stability of the passenger van involved when emergency maneuvers are undertaken and the fact that it was equipped with all-season tires.
On that first point: when any multi-passenger vehicle is fully loaded (whether it’s an SUV, minivan, full-sized or extended van, or other such vehicle), it will be less stable and more prone to fishtailing or roll-over than when empty. (Reread that statement because it bears repeating) The reason for this is because the majority of the added load is above the vehicle’s center of gravity. The taller and/or narrower the vehicle, the more susceptible it will be to these factors. The risk can be reduced by lightening the load, adding mechanical stabilizers (sway bars), electronic stability controls, or by lowering, widening, or lengthening the vehicle.
On the second point: in a climate that is adversely affected by cold temperatures and/or snow and ice, all-season tires are not a safe option. Study after study has proven that all-season tires have an increased stopping distance in colder weather or on snow- or ice-covered roads. Four snow tires cost about the same as your insurance deductible (less if you consider that they last for two or three seasons) and, as one friend of mine put it, would you rather stop before you have a collision or are you happy to just slow down?
I am not a particular fan of increased regulations designed to ‘protect us from ourselves’ (see my post on safer vehicles creating more danger), but I do feel that winter tires should be mandatory (at the very least) on commercial multi-passenger vehicles, excluding buses and other transports for which winter tires do not exist. I also welcome Transport Canada’s investigation into this crash and hope that lessons learned as a result of this tragedy are not lost.
I ask you now for a moment of silence in honour of those lost.